Key Takeaways

✓Internal ERP manager: Year 1 $196K-$341K, 5-year $623K-$1M. Partner: Year 1 $103K-$169K, 5-year $377K-$656K. Difference: $246K-$351K saved

✓Success rates: Internal 61%, Partner 85%+. 39% of internal implementations fail (timeline overruns 18-24 months, budget overruns $87K-$174K)

✓Expected value (accounting for failure): Internal $599K-$915K, Partner $349K-$543K. Difference: $250K-$372K lower with partner

✓Turnover problem: D2C hires leave in 6-12 months. Turnover cost $39K-$62K. Partner: turnover on their bench, no momentum loss

✓Case study: $2.1M fashion brand hired manager, failed after 8 months, cost $266K total. Should have been $122K with partner = $143,786 saved + 2.5 months faster

If You're Thinking About Hiring a Full-Time "ERP Manager"... Stop.

If you're thinking about hiring a full-time "ERP Manager" for your D2C brand doing $1M-$8M in revenue, stop. The math doesn't work. And the failure rate will shock you.

We've seen this movie 16 times in the past 18 months. A founder thinks: "Let's hire a smart ops person to own our ERP implementation. They'll learn Odoo. They'll fix our systems. They'll be cheaper than hiring consultants."

Then reality hits.

The "smart ops person" either burns out in 9 months or discovers they don't actually know how to structure a D2C-specific Odoo implementation.

Meanwhile, $87,000 to $174,000 in sunk costs have already walked out the door. The implementation is half-finished. Nothing works the way it should. And now you need consultants anyway—except now you're $274,000 in the hole instead of $144,000.

This is not a hypothetical scenario. We've cleaned up after this exact failure 12 times.

The Real Cost of Hiring an Internal ERP Manager

Let's do the actual math. A D2C brand doing $3M in revenue needs someone to "manage" their Odoo implementation.

You go hire an "ERP Manager." Salary: $72,000 to $96,000 per year. Looks reasonable.

But that's not the real cost.

Real Fully-Loaded Cost Year 1

Base Costs:

→ Base salary: $72,000-$96,000

→ Benefits (housing, transport, insurance): $18,000-$28,800

→ Recruiting cost (headhunter, ads, interviews): $5,000-$8,000

→ Training/professional development: $1,500-$2,500

→ Office space/equipment: $1,800-$3,000

Subtotal: $98,300-$138,300

But that's just their salary. Implementation labor overhead:

→ Backfill hiring (someone to do their old job): $18,000-$35,000

→ Overtime for their team (nights/weekends): +30-50% hours = $10,000-$25,000

→ IT department supporting other systems: +40% capacity = $7,000-$18,000

Subtotal: $35,000-$78,000

Training and change management:

→ Employee training on new processes: $8,000-$15,000

→ Change management specialist: $5,000-$12,000

→ Regression management (people quit using system): $3,000-$8,000

Subtotal: $16,000-$35,000

But the ERP Manager you hired probably doesn't know Odoo deeply. So you'll need external consultants anyway:

→ ERP consultant help (manager isn't expert enough): $25,000-$50,000

Subtotal: $25,000-$50,000

Software, hardware, and infrastructure:

→ Odoo licensing/cloud: $12,000-$24,000

→ Server/infrastructure: $8,000-$12,000

→ Training software: $2,000-$4,000

Subtotal: $22,000-$40,000

Year 1 Total: $196,300-$341,300

Year 2 Onwards

→

Salary + benefits: $95,300-$133,300

→

Maintenance: $13,000-$20,000

→

Updates/training: $5,000-$10,000

Year 2+ Total: $113,300-$163,300

5-year cost: $623,200-$1,007,200

The Hidden Cost: ERP Implementation Failure

Here's what nobody tells you: 39% of ERP implementations fail.

"Fail" doesn't mean the system doesn't work. It means:

→

Timeline overruns (18-24 months instead of 12)

→

Budget overruns ($87,000-$174,000 over budget)

→

Poorly configured (core processes don't work properly)

→

Low adoption (team resists and half-uses the system)

→

Abandoned (so much went wrong that you give up and go back to spreadsheets)

For an Internal Implementation, Failure Looks Like:

→ Your ERP manager doesn't have the expertise to navigate complex D2C requirements

→ Vendor (Odoo) asks for clarification, manager doesn't know

→ Timelines slip. Scope creeps.

→ By month 9, you realize this isn't working

→ You hire a consultant to "fix it"

→ $87,000-$174,000 later, it's finally working

(And that's if you're lucky. The alternative is you abandon the project.)

Real Example: The Manufacturing-to-D2C Disaster

One D2C fashion brand hired an "Odoo manager" from a manufacturing company. Manufacturing ≠ D2C.

The manager set up single-channel inventory (Shopify only). Didn't account for Myntra, Amazon, or the brand's own website.

After 8 months of implementation, they discovered the system couldn't handle multi-channel sync.

→ Cost to rebuild: $52,000

→ Timeline extension: 12 weeks

→ By that time, the manager had resigned

Total sunk cost: $218,000 (salary + benefits + failed implementation + recovery)

The Math on Outsourcing to a D2C-Focused Partner

Now compare that to hiring Braincuber (or another D2C-focused ERP partner).

Year 1 Costs

Partner Implementation:

→ Implementation services: $28,000-$52,000

→ Training + change management (included): $8,000-$15,000

→ Software/infrastructure: $22,000-$40,000

Year 1 Total: $58,000-$107,000

But wait, there's another cost I need to add. You'll still need someone internally to:

→ Coordinate meetings

→ Gather requirements

→ Make business decisions

→ Oversee the partner

So hire a part-time "ERP Coordinator" (not a manager) at 50% FTE:

→ Part-time salary (50%): $36,000-$48,000

→ Benefits (50%): $9,000-$14,400

Part-time coordinator: $45,000-$62,400

Real Year 1 Total with part-time coordinator: $103,000-$169,400

(Still less than the full ERP manager, and you're getting a working system.)

Year 2 Onwards

→

Software maintenance: $13,000-$20,000

→

Part-time coordinator: $45,000-$62,400

→

Ongoing support (if needed): $0-$12,000

Year 2+ Total: $58,000-$94,400

5-year cost: $377,000-$656,000

(Compare: $623,200-$1,007,200 for internal ERP manager.)

But the real difference isn't the cost. It's the success rate.

The Success Rate Difference

Internal ERP Managers

~61%

success rate on D2C implementations

That means 39% of the time, you're failing.

D2C-Focused Partners

85%+

success rate

Braincuber: 41 out of 43 successful implementations in 18 months

What's the Cost of Failure?

Failure Cost Component	Internal Manager	Partner (rare)
Sunk implementation cost	$196,300-$341,300	$103,000-$169,400
Recovery/rebuild	$52,000-$87,000	$25,000-$40,000
Timeline extension	12-24 weeks	4-8 weeks
Business disruption	$47,000-$140,000	Minimal (partner handles)
Total Failure Cost	$295,300-$568,300	$128,000-$209,400

Expected Value (Accounting for Failure Probability)

Internal Manager:

(61% × $623,200) + (39% × $568,300)

$599,000 to $915,000 expected cost

(including failure scenarios)

Partner:

(85% × $377,000) + (15% × $209,400)

$349,000 to $543,000 expected cost

(including failure scenarios)

Difference: $250,000 to $372,000 lower expected cost with a partner

The Turnover Problem You're Not Considering

Here's something most founders miss: D2C-focused ops people are rare and in high demand. And they have a habit of leaving.

A LinkedIn study found that D2C hires leave traditional organizations in 6-12 months because of culture/process friction. The new hire expects agility, fast iteration, and lean decisions. The organization offers legacy processes, layered consensus, and risk aversion.

This applies even more to ERP managers. They expect to own the implementation. But you want to micromanage. Or your CFO overrules their decisions. Friction.

What Happens When Your ERP Manager Leaves in Month 9?

→

Implementation is 60% complete

→

They've documented 40% of configurations

→

New person hired: 6-8 weeks to ramp up

→

New person finds previous person's decisions questionable: 4-6 weeks to re-evaluate

→

Delays cascade: Implementation now takes 22 months instead of 12

Total cost of turnover: $39,486-$62,000

With a partner, if there's turnover, it's on their bench. You don't care. A new consultant gets assigned, continuity is maintained. You don't lose 10 weeks.

Real Case Study: The $2.1M Fashion Brand

This brand decided to hire an ERP manager instead of partnering with Braincuber.

Their thinking: "We can save money by hiring someone smart and letting them learn Odoo on the job."

What Actually Happened

Month 1-2:

Manager set up basic Odoo structure. Only planned for Shopify sales (their original channel). No multi-channel inventory.

Month 3:

Brand launched on Myntra. Manager didn't realize multi-channel changed everything. Had to rebuild variant structure.

Month 4-5:

Attempted rebuild. Manager lacked expertise in marketplace-specific configurations. Odoo community forums and YouTube videos weren't cutting it.

Month 6:

Brand brought in Braincuber as consultant to "fix" the implementation.

Month 7-10:

Braincuber essentially re-did the entire build. Original manager felt undermined, disengaged.

Month 11:

Manager resigned.

Month 12-14:

Braincuber completed full implementation solo.

Cost Breakdown

What They Actually Paid:

→ Manager salary (11 months): $66,000

→ Benefits: $16,500

→ Recruiting: $6,500

→ Backfill + overhead: $47,300

→ Braincuber consultant fees (5 months): $62,000

→ Software/infrastructure: $28,400

→ Turnover replacement cost: $39,486

Total: $266,186

Timeline: 14 months

If They'd Partnered from the Start:

→ Braincuber implementation: $42,000

→ Part-time coordinator (12 months): $52,000

→ Software/infrastructure: $28,400

Total: $122,400

Timeline: 12 weeks

Success rate: 95%+

Difference: $143,786 saved + 2.5 months faster + better system quality

Why Partners Win on D2C Implementations

D2C-Specific Expertise

They've done this 40+ times. They know the exact pitfalls: multi-channel sync, variant matrices, RTO tracking, marketplace integrations, GST automation. Your internal hire doesn't. They're learning while you're paying.

Accountability

A partner has reputation risk. They deliver on time and on budget (usually with penalties if they don't). An internal hire has no downside to delays except, well, delays.

Dedicated Focus

A partner consultant works on your implementation 40 hours per week. Your internal hire is juggling ERP + other ops work. They'll be pulled to handle firefights.

Economies of Scale

A partner has seen 43 brands' problems. They have templated solutions. Your internal hire has only seen your problems. They'll reinvent the wheel.

Turnover Risk Elimination

If your internal hire leaves, you lose momentum and institutional knowledge. If a partner consultant changes, their firm maintains continuity.

The Bottom Line

If you're a D2C brand doing $1M-$8M in revenue and you're thinking about hiring an internal ERP manager, the math says don't.

You'll pay $246,000-$351,000 more over 5 years. You'll face a 39% failure probability. You'll lose $39,000-$62,000 if they quit. And you'll still need consultants anyway.

Partner with a D2C-focused ERP firm instead. Pay $377,000-$656,000 over 5 years (vs $623,200-$1,007,200). Get an 85%+ success rate (vs 61%). Eliminate turnover risk. And actually get a system that works.

Stop Throwing Money at the Wrong Solution

If you're considering hiring an ERP manager or already have one struggling with your D2C implementation, you're sitting on a $250,000-$372,000 expected value loss.

Free Cost-Benefit Analysis

We'll analyze your specific situation, calculate the true cost of internal vs partner implementation, quantify your failure risk, and show you the expected value difference over 5 years.

ERP for D2C

AI Ecommerce

Cloud & DevOps

D2C Operations Platform

Food & Beverage

Beauty & Personal Care

Fashion & Apparel

Home Décor & Furniture

Post Not Found